My current bag is very coarse but the buns absolutely love it, I've never seen such lovely crumbly golden poos! You can only express a 'preference' for soft or coarse though it depends on what is in stock so you might find that you just get what you're given at this time of year. I'm definitely going to carry on buying it though, it's so much more convenient than bales and I don't have to put up with hubby whingeing that I've got hay all over the car from buying a bale :lol: