I think there are some fantastic counsellors out there, which is why I suggested counselling. I went to one for over a year and he was nothing but helpful. But there are different kinds of counselling!
I think the difference is that mine was a "person centred" counsellor. He wasn't trying to fix me, or treat me, and he didn't judge or do anything other than listen to me if I wanted to talk. We would talk about whatever I wanted and he'd just listen, maybe interjecting things like "That must have been difficult," or "Did that make you feel sad?" or "I'm sorry to hear that," if necessary. Sometimes I hardly spoke at all because I was crying so hard, and he'd pass me tissues and tell me it was fine if I didn't want to talk. It was literally all about me, all the time.
And that's what I needed. I needed to get angry, or cry, or sit in silence, or complain, or just explain what I was thinking and feeling. It was just like having a heart-to-heart with your best friend about your problems without the guilt or worry that you're boring them or that you should talk about them for a bit now. None of that difficult two-way social stuff that I just wasn't in a position to do when I was feeling so bad.
Because no matter how good your friends are, there's only so long they can listen to you without making it into a conversation which you don't have full control over. My most sympathetic friends eventually became bored that I wasn't recovering "fast" enough, and although they tried very hard to hide it I could see it in their faces. And to be fair to them, I
was boring. Sometimes I upset them with the things I said, so eventually I kept things to myself.
With Mike though, I knew I could be as boring as I wanted. I could talk about the same thing week after week after week. I could just say the things I needed to say but didn't have anyone to say them to. I could tell him I wanted to die and show him my latest cuts and he didn't cry or beg me to stop or make me feel even worse about it. He just listened and was interested, and I needed that as much as I needed CBT.
Basically he wouldn't do all of the things I've done in this thread, or in the other thread.