I'm not sure if you meant that I was being hypocritical or not, but I'll assume not as I haven't said anything about cats. I agree with you, I wouldn't allow a cat of mine free range unless I lived in a very specific area (some perfect paradise where there are few to no cars, lots of houses and no countryside nearby). However, I don't think these perfect paradises exist and so I wouldn't let a cat of mine roam free. We used to let my old cat out (bearing in mind I was 13/14 at the time) and she was always fine, but we are lucky to live in a very safe area where there are very few cars and they all have to go very slow because of the roads here. As I said though, I wouldn't let mine out. You can get these aviaries which attach to the side of the house and the cat either gets out through the window or a door. Allows them to go out when they want but in a safe area.