Mine have the Ings hay, it does smell lovely and my two love it. Beano had quite a few ear problems before I adopted Gordon and I linked it with the hay so changed to Ings and she's been fine since, when the vet opened their carrier when they had some in he was like 'my, that hay smells lovely!' :lol: I got some funny looks when I used to buy pet shop hay, I used to smell which bag smelt nicest! :lol: